Holiday Dining Options
Celebrate the holiday season in Door County with festive dining and carry-out options for Christmas and New Year's. Explore restaurants offering special menus, catering, and to-go orders. Whether dining out or staying in, find everything you need for a memorable holiday!
2025
Carry-out:
Scaturo’s Baking Co. & Cafe, Sturgeon Bay
“ENJOY A CHRISTMAS DINNER AT HOME, WITHOUT DOING ANY OF THE PREPARATION, COOKING OR MAJOR CLEANUP AFTER! FROM APPETIZERS TO BREAKFAST OR DINNER TO DESSERTS, SCATURO’S CAN HELP YOU MAKE YOUR FAMILY GATHERING MUCH LESS STRESSFUL BY DOING THE COOKING AND BAKING FOR YOU! CALL OR EMAIL BERT YOUR ORDER AND WE WILL HAVE IT READY TO BE PICKED WHEN YOU NEED IT!”
Contact: chefrupp@icloud.com or 920-746-8727
Christmas Eve:
Dine-In:
Kitty O'Reilly's Irish Pub, Sturgeon Bay
Serving a select menu for Christmas Eve starting at 4pm.
Contact: 920-743-7441 to make a reservation.
Scaturo’s Baking Co & Cafe, Sturgeon Bay
Open 5am-3pm.
Contact 920-746-8727
Carry-out:
Thyme Market and Catering, Sister Bay
Orders must be placed by 4:00 PM on Friday, December 19th. Pick-up and deliveries are scheduled between 11:00 AM - 3:00 PM on Wednesday, December 24th.
Contact: Call 920-633-4012 or email contact@thymemarketandcatering.com
Nightingale Supper Club, Sturgeon Bay
Offering full or half roasts. Orders are due by Saturday night, December 20th. Pick-up is available on Wednesday, December 24th, between 12:00 PM - 2:30 PM.
Contact: Call 920-743-5593 or email info@nightingalesupperclub.com or visit website
Osteria Tre Tassi, Ellison Bay
Tre Tassi wants to make it easy for you this holiday season! Pre-order Chef Robin's take & bake Christmas meals for your holiday celebrations. All portions feed 6-8 people. Book a pick-up window on the day you'd like to pick up the order and we'll have everything ready for you when you arrive. Orders must be placed 2 days in advance of pickup. Contact: 920-309-8390 or email info@tretassi.com
Christmas Day
Dine-in:
The English Inn, Fish Creek
Serving the full menu from 12:00 PM - 7:00 PM.
Contact: Make your reservation online, call 920-868-3076
Lodge at Leathem Smith, Sturgeon Bay
Christmas Buffet. Open 3:00 PM - 7:00 PM.
Reservations are recommended. Call 920-743-5555 to reserve your table
Waterfront Mary's Bar & Grill, Sturgeon Bay
Christmas Dinner Buffet from 2 PM - 5 PM. $18.95 if purchased on Christmas Day, $12.95 if purchased in advance.
Husby's Food and Spirits, Sister Bay
Open at 4pm. Limited Menu.
New Year’s Eve
The Ellison Inn & Lounge, Ellison Bay
Offering four ways to celebrate New Year’s Eve with The Ellison Inn and Lounge
Option 1: 4pm Early Dinner Only (no entertainment or fee)
- Open to the public by reservations only for 4pm. Must call and reserve at 920-854-2928
- No added fees, no music, no entertainment or gifts
- Dinner only; guests must vacate by 5:30 PM
- Ideal for those wanting an early meal and nothing else
Option 2: 5:45pm Dinner Only (no fee unless ticket is purchased for the entertainment package.
- Open to the public by reservations only for 5:45pm. Must call and reserve at 920-854-2928
- No fee unless they decide to stay and purchase a ticket for the New Years Eve Entertainment event.
- Must vacate table no later than 7:15 PM
- Option to purchase event package ticket for $50 per person. Ticket includes access to the rest of the evening's entertainment with bar seating/standing only, no designated seating
Options 3 & 4: Premium Dinner + Entertainment Seating
- Options 3 and 4 share the same premium dining room seating, which is held for the entire evening.
- Must make reservation for dining - Must call and reserve at 920-854-2928
- Dinner reservation options between 7:30- 8:30
- Guaranteed and designated table for the night
- Instrumental Music 7:30 - 8:30 plus 5 Piece Band - 2 sets through midnight
- Midnight celebration, prizes and toast
- $50 food voucher included per person
Two ways to purchase this premium experience:
Option 3: Dinner + Entertainment Package $125 per person
- Includes all of the above listed under Premium Dinner + Entertainment Seating
Option 4: Hotel + Dinner + Entertainment Package $225 per person
- Includes all of the above listed under Premium Dinner + Entertainment Seating
plus 1-night stay at the Inn on Dec 31st.
Landmark Resort, Egg Harbor
Enjoy a 3-course dinner from 5–10pm, sip in our cocktail lounge until midnight, enjoy live music from 8–10pm, and stop by our permanent jewelry pop-up from 5–9pm for a little extra sparkle. Make a full vacation of it with 20% off your resort stay, plus get chocolate-covered strawberries and prosecco delivered to your room
Inn at Cedar Crossing, Sturgeon Bay
Open at 4 PM, with the last seating at 10 PM
Contact: Call 920-743-4200 to make a reservation.
Osteria Tre Tassi, Ellison Bay
Join us for New Year's Eve as we celebrate with Robin's special five-course prix fixe menu! Reservations open December 14th at Noon!
The Mill Supper Club, Sturgeon Bay
Full Menu available. Dinner service starts at 5 PM.
Contact: 920-743-5044
Thyme Restaurant, Sister Bay
Open 4:30 PM - 10:00 PM.
Contact: Call 920-421-5113 to make a reservation.
Villaggios Italian Steakhouse, Egg Harbor
Open 4:00 PM - 9:00 PM. Reservations welcome!
Contact: Call 920-890-2190 or book online at mojorestaurantgroup.com/villaggios.
Restaurants having live music:
Log Den: New Year’s Eve Celebration
Featuring country and rock music by Day Drifters (8:30pm-12:30am)
Harbor Ridge Winery
Austin Skalecki; blues, rock & folk
1pm-4pm
Door 44 Winery
Sam Sturdevant; 90s & 00s favorites
1pm-4pm
Nightingale
Small Forest; variety of musical flavors from folk and ballads to indie-pop
5pm-8pm
Brygga Plats & Pours
New Year’s Eve Bash; live country rock music
9pm
Waterfront Mary's Bar & Grill, Sturgeon Bay
5:30pm - Fish Boil (reservations required)
9pm- Live Music by Ryan Thompson & Runaway Turkey
