Hunting for Mushrooms
in Door County

Hunting for Mushrooms in Door County

Door County’s edible wild mushrooms are as easy to find on the plates at local restaurants as they are in the damp woods throughout the peninsula. Morels may be the favorite, but everything from chanterelles to black trumpets dot the county waiting to be cooked up in your favorite dish.

Author Charlotte Lukes has identified more than 550 varieties of mushrooms in Door County, and often leads hikes to find and identify them. 

“The shapes and colors and sizes of mushrooms are always a delight," she says. "You come upon some that are brilliant red and deep orange and yellow. There are a few that I’ve found that were purple. It’s like going on a treasure hunt.” 

First, a few general rules of mushroom treasure hunt:

  1. You can collect mushrooms in all Wisconsin State Parks, but not in state natural areas.
  2. Be sure to check with any public lands or reserves before hunting.
  3. They are best found a day or two after a rainfall.
  4. Look near fallen trees and other decomposing areas of the forest.
  5. Double check which mushrooms you find with an expert before eating them.

Here’s a breakdown of the most popular edible wild mushrooms to find in the area and some ideas on what to do with them.

Morels

Commonly found starting in early spring when the ground temperature reaches above 40 degrees, morels can spring up overnight after a particularly wet couple of days. They tend to grow in clusters so if you find one, there are probably more nearby. Pair the morel with other light spring foods like asparagus and halibut. Otherwise, a little butter in a frying pan never fails with these elusive fungi.

Chanterelles

These fragrant mushrooms pop up in the hardwood forests in the heat of the summer. With consistent summer rains, the chanterelle can be found well into the fall. Chanterelle risotto is a favorite dish of some local chefs while its light apricot scent can serve well with any grain.

Black trumpets

Although a bit more elusive given their ability to blend in with the forest floor, the taste of these hardwood-loving mushrooms is worth the hunt. Often appearing as little black holes in the ground, they are most easily spotted by seeing them from directly above, so keep your eye on the ground.

When cooking, flash fry them to hold onto their dark, earthy flavor and then toss them with dark greens, pine nuts and a light citrus vinaigrette for a summer salad.

Sulfur shelf

Chicken of the woods and hen of the woods are the two common names given to these mushrooms that grow like shelves off of trees. They often have a vibrant red color near the tree trunk that becomes yellow towards the edges. This yellow part is your meal and the name doesn’t lie. Use this mushroom as a substitute for chicken in soup or stir fry. As a warning, some stomachs just don’t jive with the sulfur shelf mushrooms, so it’s best to try just a little bit at first.

Puffball

These soccer ball-looking mushrooms don’t offer much in the way of flavor, but they are fun to find. The biggest one ever found was more than five feet wide. The big white balls are best served fried, but you can add them to a miso soup if you’re feeling adventurous.