Sweetie Pies, LLC

On the bluffs above the village of Fish Creek, Sweetie Pies offers a scrumptious selection of handmade pies. Our customers say nobody makes them better, except maybe Grandma! Our cozy little shop is part of the Settlement Shops right next to Fish Creek’s popular Settlement Courtyard Inn. Started as a family business in 1995, it features patio and indoor dining all year. In addition to pies of 30 flavors and 2 sizes, we offer crust cookies, handmade chocolates and an assortment of gifts.

Categories: Markets/Specialty Foods, Confectionery/Ice Cream, Open in Winter - Shopping

Winter Hours

Nov-Apr, Sa-M 10-4.

Reviews & Ratings

I:568 W:428 S:0 R:0


Want to learn more about Door County?

Sign up for Door County's monthly newsletter and receive vacation itineraries, travel tips and ideas, event announcements, and exclusive giveaways in your inbox.

No Thanks